Home / PASTORAL ISSUES / Nothing equal about this debate
Nothing equal about this debate

Nothing equal about this debate

Quote regarding no bullshit tolerance

THE homosexual marriage lobby likes to claim it plants its rainbow-coloured flags firmly on the summit of the high moral ground.

Diversity has been its catch cry.

But it is quick to stiffly opposing viewpoints. Like those of the new Marriage Alliance.

The group, launched last weekend, supports the Marriage Act and wants to start a proper debate on same sex marriage.

It not unreasonably asks whether the rights of children are being subjugated by arguments about equality between gay and heterosexual adults. It says that the more important issues about the consequences and the rights of future generations, sex ­education, religious freedoms, morality, business and ­professional regulations, and legal implications resulting from ­permitting same-sex marriage haven’t been thoroughly ­examined.

The spokesperson for the marriage alliance is Sydney barrister, Sophie York, a published author, an instructor in International Humanitarian Law (IHL), and member of a number of boards, committees and associations. York insists there is absolutely no intention to denigrate the gay community, devalue them or their relationships. She says that would be wrong and unjust and the aim of the campaign is to focus on the erosion of rights and freedoms currently allowed in our democracy.

To this end, a group of individuals, businesses and community organisations who are concerned that the Australian people are not getting the full story on the implications of changing the Act, funded a 15-second television ad which basically does no more than say that the Marriage Alliance exists and shows its web address — ­marriagealliance.com.au

But a few television channels including 7 and 10 and some radio networks have refused to run the totally innocuous commercial — although a Seven spokesman said there was no politics in the ­decision and the station didn’t have a 15-second spot.

That’s their right, of course, but if these supporters of what they like to call marriage equality ever claim to support diversity or free speech they won’t have a leg to stand on.



A television ad suggesting there’s more to same sex marriage than has been considered so far in public debates has been denied airings on Channel 10, Channel 7 and some radio stations this week.

The ad campaign, titled “There’s more to it than you think,” was created by newly formed group the Marriage Alliance and launched this week in Sydney. The ads depict same-sex marriage arguments around equality as just the “tip of the iceberg” of issues that haven’t yet had a proper public airing.

The ad lists issues such as “how [same sex marriage] will affect children or sex education in schools or even what rights you could lose” as some of the “important issues” that “are taking a back seat” in the current same-sex marriage debates.

The Marriage Alliance called the decision by Channel 7 and 10 a “black-ban”, while the Australian Christian Lobby was quick to comment on the decision, suggesting that political viewpoints were being “censored”.

“This is a chilling display of the dangerous tendency to censor debate on marriage,” said ACL’s managing director Lyle Shelton.

The advertising campaign was seeking advertising spots “over the next few weeks,” according to the Marriage Alliance, in the lead up to an expected vote on same-sex marriage in the next federal parliamentary sitting that starts on Monday. Marriage Alliance has received confirmation from Channel 9 and Foxtel that the ad will air from this week on those stations.

Eternity asked Channel 7’s director of corporate affairs, Simon Francis, why the decision was made not to run the Marriage Alliance ads. In an email, Mr Francis said, “We could not accommodate the booking request.”

Daily Telegraph columnist Piers Akerman today heard a similar story from Channel 7. “A Seven spokesman said there was no politics in the decision and the station didn’t have a 15-second spot.”

The Marriage Alliance website features a countdown for when politicians will “return [to Canberra] to vote on same-sex marriage”. A multi-party marriage equality bill is expected to be moved in Parliament during the next sitting. At time of writing, the Marriage Alliance countdown was two days, 18 hours, 52 minutes.

So, could the Marriage Alliance have just asked for the ads too late?

Marriage Alliance spokesperson Sophie York doesn’t think so. Another Marriage Alliance spokesperson told Eternity they had booked ads on Channel 7 and 10 and had them “locked in” two weeks ago. But last week both channels responded by saying the bookings could not be made, though Marriage Alliance received nothing in writing.

“We can only then deduce that we’re being subject to a ban, a last-minute refusal. We can only go on what’s presented to us … they accepted the booking and there’s been no grounds provided for why they can’t run them,” said Ms York. “It doesn’t add up.”

“It is quite shocking that two major TV networks are denying the basic right to freedom of speech and expression on an issue that supports the current law of the nation,” Ms York said.

In March, a television ad from the Australian Marriage Forum intended to be screened during the Sydney Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras was pulled by SBS. It urged Australians to “think of the child” when considering same-sex marriage. While SBS did not allow the ad, saying it reserved the right to determine what adverts it broadcasts, the ad was aired on Channel 7 and Channel 9.

Ms York said that the climate must have changed for Channel 7. “It shows that something’s changed at 7. Channel 9 are clearly still open to all comers, and happy to have different view points put forward.”

Australian Marriage Equality, the campaign group that supports same sex-marriage, has a fundraising campaign open to create TV ads to “ensure MPs and senators who have not yet declared this position [on same-sex marriage] see it.” Whether Channel 7 and 10 will air those ads remains to be seen.

Zero Tolerance


Over the last few weeks have you experienced that awful feeling deep in your gut that the national discussion on same sex marriage does not seem balanced? Perhaps the media is biased? Perhaps those in favour of man woman marriage are being railroaded into social change without a proper national discussion? Well the following will confirm your gut instincts. The following should cause a sense of outrage and sadness. Yes, freedom of speech is under attack!

We have just been informed that Channels 7 and 10 banned an advertisement that asked people to think carefully about the consequences of redefining marriage. We have just seen the ad and it is not offensive. We urge you to watch the ad below and contact Channels 7 and 10 asking them why they have banned the ad. Let’s send them a message that TV channels should not gag freedom of speech.

What you can do:
Please contact Channel 7 and Channel 10 today.


Comment on Channel 7 Facebook or twitter

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/pages/Channel-Seven/158415237510331

Twitter: https://twitter.com/channel7

Or, Write to the Complaints Officer

PO BOX 777


or by fax to: (02) 8777 7180


Comment on Channel 10 Facebook or twitter

email:  contactus@networkten.com.au

Or phone  Channel 7 (02) 8777 7777  or  Channel 10 (02) 9650 1010

About Mode of Life

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *